Taylor’s Bakery — 6216 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis

What’s in the case

The things people keep naming

Every line below is something a customer named in a Google review or something that shows up in the bakery’s own photographs. The case is bigger than this list — this is just the part we can prove from the outside.

One real receipt

Three donuts, a cookie, a bear claw, a dozen donut holes and a cinnamon roll — about $17. They were handed samples before they’d ordered anything.

Photographed at the counter

All of it came out of this kitchen

Two iced cinnamon twists on a wooden board — Cinnamon twists

A quiche in a foil tin with one slice cut out — Quiche, sliced

A cherry pie seen from above with one slice on a plate beside it — Cherry pie

A round white cake piped with blue and pink roses reading Boy or girl, sitting in an open bakery box — Boxed, and on its way to a party

★★★★★

4.7

across 1,589 Google reviews.

Tue–Sat · 7am to 5pm

Made to order

Cakes are the reason people call

Weddings, birthdays, an 87th. Three tiers with piped swags, or one round in a box with your words across the top. Order online, over the phone, or by standing at the counter and describing it.

(317) 251-9575

Call about a cake Order online →

Three ways to order — online, by phone, or in person.

Lead times and deposits aren’t published anywhere. Call and ask; you’ll get a straight answer.

A cake takes a phone call. A donut doesn’t.

A three-tier white wedding cake with piped swags and buttercream roses on a pillared stand — Three tiers · piped swags · buttercream roses

What the neighborhood says

4.7 ★★★★★
1,589 Google reviews
Read them on Google →

Real reviews, real names, pulled straight
from the Google listing. None of this
was written by us.

★★★★★

“They offered us samples without even asking. (The donut holes were amazing BTW!) … both the workers were so patient with all of them, explaining what each dessert was and what it was made with.”

Alexandrea Rivera · 3 months ago

★★★★★

“We celebrated my Great Aunt’s ‘87th’ Birthday with a really beautiful and delicious Cake by Taylor’s and the family give it ALL 10’s across the board!!”

Freddie Knox · 2 months ago

★★★★★

“Whether you order online, phone or in person they are always on! We get all of our cakes here & oh my they are so good I can’t even describe it!”

Julie · 3 weeks ago

Find us

6216 Allisonville Rd
Indianapolis, IN 46220
(317) 251-9575

Seven in the morning the case is full, and by five it isn’t. There is no Sunday and no Monday here — the two days most bakeries need off and most websites forget to mention. Come early for donuts. Call ahead for cake.

Credit, debit, and tap to pay
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Storefront in the strip center, parking straight out front

Get directions Call the bakery

Hours as listed on Google. Holidays run differently at every bakery — call ahead for Thanksgiving and Christmas Eve.

The Taylor's Bakery storefront in daylight, blue letters above the windows — Blue letters on the tan strip center. If you can read the sign from Allisonville, you’re already in the right lot.